Canadian Cancer Society doesn’t get it that substituting vaping for smoking is no different than quitting smoking

The Canadian Cancer Society took the opportunity of ramping up the concerns raised by a fairly even-handed report issued by the Institut national de la santé publique du Québec on e-cigarette products being mislabeled. The report found varying levels of nicotine in supposedly nicotine free e-cigarettes.

Now I am all for precise description of contents, and I know first hand that this is a major concern of reputable e-cigarette producers and retailers, however I can’t help but think that making too much hay out of these mislabeled products comes from continuing to treat nicotine as a horribly toxic substance.

Imagine if you tested a number of decaffeinated products and found they contained some caffeine.  Sure, that has to change.  It is wrong but would there be the same hullabaloo about some minimal amounts showing up in the product?

If we are agreed that the dangers of nicotine are nothing much too worry about then why should it matter for the consumer if they get a little bit of it.  As with caffeine, the user will sense it and if they don’t like it, reject it for another brand.  What really is nice about both caffeine and nicotine is that you can control the amount you take in over time, and if you sense that there is more than you like, you can immediately stop with no real lasting discomfort.

But to reiterate in case I am misunderstood, I am not defending wrong labelling – I am just saying that in this case it will not have much of an impact.

The Society then reported on a commissioned study which found that nearly a quarter of 18-24 years old had used e-cigarettes in the past year while in the general population the percentage was only about 9%.  They then reported that as much as 60% of youth had reported using them.  I have a hard time understanding how the figures interact and no link is given to the actual results.

But then they say that quitting smoking was not the main concern of these users. What I find fascinating is that these organizations will complain that these are not quit smoking devices and then complain that people are not using them to quit smoking.


I find any report of the rise of e-cigarettes in the 18-24 age group encouraging. It is a good thing if these people can switch now rather than after decades of smoking.  And the CCS should understand that the more you vape the less likely you are to smoke.

And all those “kid-friendly” flavours (in other words, flavours that any human being of any age might prefer to tobacco-flavouring) might have helped get those adults to try and move over to vaping.

Not only does the CCS not get that fighting these products tooth and nail goes against their mandate to prevent cancer but that there are no good arguments against moving a flavoured gas in and out of your lungs if it doesn’t harm you (or for that matter either someone seeing you moving that gas or airing an advertisement to engage in the same activity).

5 thoughts on “Canadian Cancer Society doesn’t get it that substituting vaping for smoking is no different than quitting smoking

  1. Pingback: Canadian Cancer Society doesn't get it that sub...

  2. Pingback: Canadian Cancer Society doesn’t get it that substituting vaping for smoking is no different than quitting smoking | vapeforlife

  3. It has been almost 2 years since I “changed” to a electronic cigarettes / personal vaporiser. I use it as “an Alternative” to cigarettes/tobacco. My health is much better since the switch! I can breathe better, sleep better, have alot more energy. No cigarette butts to pollute the earth, no empty packs laying around. No lingering smell in the air , on my clothes or on me. My sense of smell is better, sense of taste is awesome and feel way better about myself. All my non-smoking friends and even strangers appreciate it. No second hand smoke, no annoying smell. All there is with Electronic Cigarettes is positive things! Health Canada, you are so WRONG in banning these. Do not turn this into a Tobacco product! There is NO tobacco in these!

    At this moment, you are forcing cigarettes on us, or other tobacco products, and we don’t want them. We want a non Big Pharma Alternative. Our choice. Not Your Alternative. This is why we are fighting you Health Canada, for OUR FREEDOM to choose. The choice to use an Alternative form of delivery of Nicotine into our bodies. One that works for us.. Not one that you choose for us or that Big Pharma companies create.

    If you want to put Electronic Cigarettes into the Tobacco Act, then you MUST also add Nicorette, the patch, the gum, the inhaler the spray, ALL Nicotine products. E-Cigs are no different than these products. They are not cigarettes.

    No Tobacco, NOT a tobacco product.

    FREEDOM to choose.

  4. I think it’s important to have freedom of choice, however, when we are talking about nicotine; there ought to be an appreciation and understanding just how powerful this drug is. Most people who may be addicted to other substances like cocaine or heroin along with tobacco will have more difficulty giving up tobacco.

    The power and nature of addiction is “absence of choice” or else there is no addiction. Addiction, in my mind, means I have no choice despite consequences until or unless I am able to come to terms with this reality. Addicts left with making thier own choices tend to repeat use.

    Two components that pose risk are; “susceptability and availability”. You may be susceptable, however, if substance is not readiliy availble then risk is significantly reduced.

    Two sides-One Coin!~

  5. Hi Gary,
    I just can’t take addiction to relatively harmless drugs like caffeine or nicotine seriously. These do not affect my work or social life. I have also heard from people who attempted to give up caffeine that that was worse than the others. I don’t see my attachment to caffeine as indicative of either the strength of caffeine or whether or not it is good for me.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s